Steak Showdown: Ribeye vs. New York Strip—The Ultimate Grill Comparison

How to Judge Two Iconic Steak Cuts Side by Side

In this editorial exploration, Ryan Maya examines two heavyweight steak cuts—the richly marbled ribeye and the lean New York strip—using the same grilling process for each. By patting, seasoning, searing, and finishing them under identical conditions, he reveals the subtle differences in flavor, texture, and crust development that make each cut unique.

Setting the Stage

To begin, the grill was brought up to its highest temperature—approaching seven hundred degrees Fahrenheit—to ensure a rapid sear. Such intense heat creates the Maillard crust that defines a great steak. While the grates heated, both steaks were laid out and patted completely dry. Any residual moisture would steam the surface and prevent the formation of that coveted golden crust.

Drying and Seasoning

With the grill roaring, each steak was evenly coated in coarse sea salt and freshly cracked black pepper. This classic seasoning duo highlights the natural beef taste while building the savory outer layer. Because both cuts are substantial in thickness, every square inch received its share of seasoning. After seasoning, the steaks rested briefly at room temperature so the salt could begin drawing out surface moisture and dissolving into the meat.

The High-Heat Sear

Once the grill reached peak temperature, the ribeye and New York strip were placed at a forty-five-degree angle on the hottest section of the grate to maximize contact. The instant sizzle confirmed the grates were sufficiently hot. After two minutes, each steak was rotated by another forty-five degrees to produce crosshatch grill marks, then seared for an additional minute before flipping to the other side. The rapid crust formation during this process is what delivers both flavor and texture.

Finishing on Indirect Heat

After both sides were seared, the steaks were moved to the cooler zone of the grill, where ambient heat could gently raise their internal temperature without risking overbrowning. A probe thermometer monitored the progress until each cut reached an internal reading of one hundred and twenty-five degrees Fahrenheit—ideal for medium rare. This method preserves the crispy exterior while ensuring uniform doneness throughout.

Slicing and Side-by-Side Tasting

With both steaks pulled from the grill at the same target temperature, they rested on a cutting board to allow juices to redistribute. Slicing into the ribeye first revealed a lush, buttery interior framed by a deep mahogany crust. The New York strip followed, presenting a firmer bite and an evenly pink center edged by its seasoning. In direct comparison, the strip exhibited a cleaner, more pronounced beef flavor, while the ribeye offered a richer, more indulgent mouthfeel thanks to its abundant marbling.

Conclusion

Neither cut outright wins this match up—each brings distinct qualities that cater to different preferences. The New York strip appeals to those who appreciate a bold, beefy bite with precise seasoning, while the ribeye enchants with its tender, melt-in-the-mouth texture and robust marbling. By testing both under identical conditions, you can decide which steak reigns supreme in your own barbecue kingdom.

---

Ryan Maya is the creator and voice of RyanMayaCooks, where he demystifies grilling and steak cooking with approachable, step-by-step techniques. A passionate home cook and barbecue enthusiast, he specializes in teaching readers how to achieve restaurant-quality results whether it’s mastering a perfect New York strip or smoking fall-off-the-bone ribs, using simple tools and straightforward methods.

Connect with Ryan Maya on Instagram @ryanmayacooks | YouTube RyanMayaCooks | TikTok @ryanmayacooks